The $15M Gamble on DIY Wills: Why New Yorkers Should Be Cautious
The news recently broke that Trust & Will, a prominent online platform for do-it-yourself (DIY) estate planning, successfully raised another $15 million in funding. This is not an isolated event; it represents a powerful and accelerating trend. Venture capitalists are pouring tens of millions of dollars into “legal tech” companies that promise to democratize estate planning, making it as easy as ordering a product online. The message is clear: the future of creating a will or trust is digital, cheap, and instantaneous.
As a New York attorney with over 30 years of experience navigating the intricate and deeply personal world of estate law, I view this trend with a mixture of appreciation and profound concern. The awareness these platforms bring to the importance of planning is positive. However, the narrative that a complex legal strategy can be safely reduced to a fill-in-the-blank web form is fraught with danger. An estate plan is not a product; it is a process of counsel, foresight, and custom legal drafting. At Morgan Legal Group, we believe that while technology is an excellent tool, it is a poor substitute for the wisdom and fiduciary care of a human expert. This article will delve into what this mainstream push for digital estate planning means for you and why the “convenience” offered often conceals a minefield of risk.
The Mainstream Appeal: Why DIY Platforms Attract Millions
To understand the risks, we must first acknowledge why these platforms are so successful. Their business model is brilliantly tailored to modern consumer expectations and addresses the primary reasons people fail to create an estate plan.
The Promise of Affordability
The most compelling sales pitch is price. A DIY will can be generated for a fraction of the cost of hiring an experienced attorney. For individuals and young families who perceive their financial situation as “simple,” the choice between a few hundred dollars and a few thousand seems obvious. This makes planning feel accessible to everyone, not just the wealthy.
Unmatched Convenience
In our on-demand world, convenience is king. Online platforms allow users to create legal documents from their living room, at any time of day or night. There are no appointments to schedule, no travel to a law office in New York City, and no need to take time off work. The process is self-paced and fits into a busy lifestyle.
Simplicity and Accessibility
The legal world can be intimidating. These platforms replace complex legal jargon with simple questionnaires and a step-by-step process. This user-friendly interface makes the task feel less daunting and empowers users with a sense of control and accomplishment, helping them overcome the natural tendency to procrastinate on a difficult subject.
These are powerful motivators. However, they all rest on a flawed premise: that creating a legally sound estate plan is a simple matter of data entry. The reality is far more complex.
The Critical Distinction: A Document is Not Counsel
The fundamental misunderstanding promoted by the DIY model is the confusion between a legal *document* and legal *counsel*. An online platform sells you a document. A law firm provides you with counsel. These are not the same thing.
Think of it this way: WebMD can provide you with a detailed article about abdominal pain (the document), but it cannot diagnose the specific cause of your pain or prescribe a course of treatment (the counsel). Only a doctor, after a thorough examination and by asking nuanced questions, can do that. Similarly, a DIY platform can generate a will, but it cannot diagnose the hidden risks in your family structure, your asset portfolio, or your long-term goals. It cannot provide a legal strategy. For that, you need a lawyer.
The Inability to Ask “Why?”
A software program can ask, “Who do you want to be your Executor?” But it can’t ask the crucial follow-up questions an attorney would:
- “You’ve named your oldest son. Is he financially responsible? Does he get along with his siblings?”
- “He lives out of state. Are you aware that in New York, he may need to post a bond, which can be costly?”
- “Given the potential for conflict in your family, have you considered appointing a neutral professional fiduciary instead?”
This dialogue—this process of discovery and strategic thinking—is the very essence of legal counsel. It’s a process that a template, no matter how sophisticated, can never replicate.
The Unseen Risks: A Minefield for the Unwary
The true cost of a DIY estate plan is not its sticker price. It’s the potential for catastrophic errors that are often not discovered until after you are gone, leaving your family to pay the price—both emotionally and financially.
Risk 1: Flawed Execution and the Invalid Will
New York has very strict and formal requirements for signing and witnessing a will (known as the “execution ceremony”). A misplaced signature, an incorrect attestation clause, or a witness who is also a beneficiary can invalidate the entire document. An attorney from a firm like Morgan Legal Group supervises this ceremony to ensure it is legally perfect. A DIY service simply provides a set of instructions, leaving you to navigate this legal minefield alone. If you get it wrong, your will is worthless.
Risk 2: The Empty Box—An Unfunded Trust
Many online platforms now sell revocable living trusts, marketing them as the best way to avoid probate. They will generate the trust document, but the most crucial step is what comes next: “funding” the trust. This means legally re-titling your assets (the deed to your house, your bank accounts) into the name of the trust. A trust that holds no assets is a useless, empty box. This is the single most common failure of DIY trust planning, and it completely negates the primary benefit of creating the trust in the first place.
Risk 3: The Beneficiary Designation Trap
Your will does not control all of your assets. Life insurance and retirement accounts (like 401(k)s and IRAs) are passed on through beneficiary designation forms. These designations override your will. A DIY plan is siloed; it cannot perform a holistic review of all your assets. This frequently leads to tragic, unintended consequences, such as an ex-spouse inheriting a multi-million-dollar retirement account because the beneficiary form was never updated after a divorce.
Risk 4: One Size Fits None—The Failure to Handle Complexity
The “simple” family situation is largely a myth. A software template is incapable of addressing the beautiful and messy complexities of real life.
- Blended Families: A standard will can easily lead to the children of the first spouse to die being disinherited. Protecting all parties requires sophisticated trust planning, often involving complex family law considerations.
- Beneficiaries with Special Needs: Leaving money directly to a disabled individual can jeopardize their access to essential government benefits. A Special Needs Trust, a highly specialized document, is required.
- Business Owners: A DIY plan offers no mechanism for business succession planning.
- Long-Term Care Needs: A standard will or trust does nothing to protect your assets from the catastrophic cost of a nursing home. This requires specialized elder law planning.
Risk 5: Ignoring New York’s Specific Legal Landscape
A generic template may not account for the specific nuances of New York law. For example:
- The Spousal Right of Election: You cannot completely disinherit a spouse in New York. They are entitled to an “elective share” of your estate, regardless of what your will says.
- The Estate Tax “Cliff”:
An experienced New York attorney like Russel Morgan, Esq., builds a plan specifically designed to navigate these local laws.
The Irreplaceable Value of an Attorney: Your Fiduciary and Guide
When you hire an estate planning attorney, you are not just buying a document. You are entering into a professional relationship with a fiduciary who is legally and ethically bound to act in your best interest. That is a world away from the customer-vendor relationship you have with a software company.
Holistic and Strategic Counsel
An attorney’s process begins with a conversation, not a questionnaire. We listen to your story, understand your goals, and then design a customized strategy. We can help you navigate complex decisions like choosing a guardian for your children or creating a plan to minimize family conflict. We plan for your incapacity with a durable power of attorney and health care proxy, not just for your death.
Protection from Liability and Conflict
A well-drafted plan is your best defense against a future will contest. An attorney can help create a record to defend against claims of undue influence or lack of capacity. For the fiduciaries you name (your Executor or Trustee), the attorney’s guidance is an invaluable shield, protecting them from personal liability by ensuring they follow the law correctly. This is critical in sensitive situations involving potential elder abuse or a contested guardianship.
A Lifelong Relationship
An estate plan is not a static document. It must be reviewed and updated as your life changes. Your attorney becomes a trusted family advisor. When you have a question or face a major life event, you have a professional to call who already understands your situation inside and out. This long-term relationship is one of the most valuable, yet intangible, benefits of professional counsel. You can find more information about the benefits of professional advice from authoritative sources like the Forbes Advisor.
The Real Meaning of the “Mainstream” Trend
The $15 million investment in Trust & Will and similar platforms confirms that estate planning is no longer a niche concern. The public is aware of its importance. However, it also signals a dangerous trend towards the “commoditization” of a deeply personal legal service. It creates the illusion that protecting your legacy is a simple, transactional event.
The truth is that you get what you pay for. A cheap, templated document provides a cheap, templated level of protection. It may be better than nothing, but “better than nothing” is a terrifyingly low bar when your family’s future security is at stake. The families who come to our office in Brooklyn or our other locations are not looking for a template; they are looking for certainty.
Conclusion: Don’t Gamble With Your Legacy
The rise of digital estate planning is a powerful market force, but it does not change the fundamental truth: there is no substitute for the personalized counsel of an experienced attorney. Your life is not simple. Your family is not a template. Your legacy deserves more than a fill-in-the-blank form.
The millions being invested in these platforms are a bet that consumers will choose perceived convenience over genuine security. At Morgan Legal Group, we have placed our 30-year bet on the opposite: that discerning New Yorkers will always understand the profound value of entrusting their most important planning to a human expert who has their back. Don’t let your life’s work become a cautionary tale of a DIY plan gone wrong.
If you are ready to create a comprehensive, robust estate plan that truly protects what you hold dear, we invite you to experience the difference professional counsel makes. Contact Morgan Legal Group today for a consultation. You can learn more about our commitment to our clients by visiting us on Google.
The post Trust & Will’s $15M: Is DIY Estate Planning Safe? appeared first on Morgan Legal Group PC.
